Poems, work in progress, short reviews and random thoughts from an eccentric neoRomantic.
Thursday, September 7, 2017
Afternoon Walk through Downtown Pittsburgh
I walked nine miles today and took 213 photos. The walk started and ended in downtown Pittsburgh. You can see some of them in this Flickr album.
Brett's Afternoon Walk in Pittsburgh Photo Album
Union Trust Building
The Gothic gingerbread atop the Union Trust Building gives little clue to what is inside: a classic lobby with an atrium that goes all the way up to the top of the building. It looks like some kind of video game, but this is real.
You can see all the photos I took on my Flickr page.
Brett's Flickr Page for Union Trust
You can see all the photos I took on my Flickr page.
Brett's Flickr Page for Union Trust
Wednesday, September 6, 2017
One Night in Cyprus
This is a story I have waited decades to tell. One night in 1974 I had an intense dream, in which I was inside another person's mind and body. I was on the island of Cyprus, escaping by night from an unspecified peril. This poem relates the dream, exactly as it occurred. By the end of the next day, the world knew that a Greek junta-led coup had taken over Cyprus, and its Greek leader, Archbishop Makarios, had fled. These events led to a Turkish invasion and the permanent partition of Cyprus.
On
the back of a truck
hurtling without headlamps
on a moonlit night on Cyprus,
the archbishop sat, cross-legged.
hurtling without headlamps
on a moonlit night on Cyprus,
the archbishop sat, cross-legged.
He saw great
silhouettes of cedar trees
and overhanging crags black-edged,
an open sky of fierce and unnamed stars —
and overhanging crags black-edged,
an open sky of fierce and unnamed stars —
stars whose names
he’d never learned,
though Greek and Arab astronomers
had classed and ordered them,
hard-tracing beasts and maidens,
hunters and bears, cup-bearers loyal
to the rampant, seducing cosmos,
though Greek and Arab astronomers
had classed and ordered them,
hard-tracing beasts and maidens,
hunters and bears, cup-bearers loyal
to the rampant, seducing cosmos,
now a mere tapestry
for Christ’s passing.
Now he, a mariner without sail or star
had put his trust in strangers (strangers
who came from god and might be god),
hidden like thief beneath a flapping tarp,
a lump among fogs and onions
inhaling the incense of root earth.
Now he, a mariner without sail or star
had put his trust in strangers (strangers
who came from god and might be god),
hidden like thief beneath a flapping tarp,
a lump among fogs and onions
inhaling the incense of root earth.
The driver stopped,
the men
invisible to him in the truck cab
invisible to him in the truck cab
came ’round to
lift the tarp. He winced.
You may stretch your legs, Father.
We have reached the peak —
So far no sign of any soldiers.
We’ll send a scout ahead on foot,
the crossroads below a last point
of danger we’ll be stopped and captured.
You may stretch your legs, Father.
We have reached the peak —
So far no sign of any soldiers.
We’ll send a scout ahead on foot,
the crossroads below a last point
of danger we’ll be stopped and captured.
He
nodded, thanked and blessed them,
his hand making the crossroads sign
as he thought of the feared places
where Hecate was summoned and fetuses
buried. Thus one always shuddered at crossroads.
his hand making the crossroads sign
as he thought of the feared places
where Hecate was summoned and fetuses
buried. Thus one always shuddered at crossroads.
He
walked to road-edge. If ever a prayer
was called for, it was now. No altar, no walls.
was called for, it was now. No altar, no walls.
The arched cedar
tree cupped praying hands,
the slope was dotted with flowers —
what color, the asphodel at midnight?
the slope was dotted with flowers —
what color, the asphodel at midnight?
He said some words,
not for himself at first,
then for himself, for so much depended
on his getting out and away, to save the country.
But where, in dark night, did prayers go?
then for himself, for so much depended
on his getting out and away, to save the country.
But where, in dark night, did prayers go?
* * *
I never knew you. I
never heard of you.
I have never seen
Cyprus, and yet the dream
that seized me was realer than real.
I felt the pain of your bones, I sighed your sigh
as you knelt and prayed. I did not grasp the words
or the language in which they were uttered.
Yet my self watching myself dreaming told me:
that seized me was realer than real.
I felt the pain of your bones, I sighed your sigh
as you knelt and prayed. I did not grasp the words
or the language in which they were uttered.
Yet my self watching myself dreaming told me:
this is Cyprus, and
this is happening.
Your prayer, for whatever cause, rose not to heaven:
Your prayer, for whatever cause, rose not to heaven:
it came to me, an
atheist, and half a world away.
You fled the
Greek-led coup on Cyprus, a hunted man,
and you escaped that night; you flew to London.
You returned to endure a Turkish invasion.
Your statue stands in Nicosia.
Why you, why me, Archbishop Makarios?
and you escaped that night; you flew to London.
You returned to endure a Turkish invasion.
Your statue stands in Nicosia.
Why you, why me, Archbishop Makarios?
Wartime Fragment
Bellum
ante
inter
post
ante
inter
post
was this a just war,
an old men’s war?
a war of merchants who wanted their weapons used
so that the great treasures of two kingdoms passed|
o, into their hands, Vulcan’s malevolent sons?
a war of merchants who wanted their weapons used
so that the great treasures of two kingdoms passed|
o, into their hands, Vulcan’s malevolent sons?
O the why and
wherefore of war, what reckoning
your heirs will make of it, beside a ruined tomb!
your heirs will make of it, beside a ruined tomb!
Nero and the Flamingo
He is the Emperor
of the known universe:
Rome, that is,
and of every place
worth having.
of the known universe:
Rome, that is,
and of every place
worth having.
The gods are best
pleased
by ever-more-exotic
sacrifices.
No lowly chickens here
in Rome whose temples
all but outstrip Olympus.
Give up the cattle to Jove,
and to that upstart Mithra;
meek lambs and smelly rams
fit only for Judean
hecatombs. No,
only the best for Nero,
the whole menagerie
if need be, to assure
his eventual,
glorious godhood.
by ever-more-exotic
sacrifices.
No lowly chickens here
in Rome whose temples
all but outstrip Olympus.
Give up the cattle to Jove,
and to that upstart Mithra;
meek lambs and smelly rams
fit only for Judean
hecatombs. No,
only the best for Nero,
the whole menagerie
if need be, to assure
his eventual,
glorious godhood.
Today he picks a
stately
bird, a solitary feeder
that keeps to its own corner
in a flush of pink feathers.
Hook-nose wary,
it is a half-arm taller
than his Centurions.
He waits at the altar.
bird, a solitary feeder
that keeps to its own corner
in a flush of pink feathers.
Hook-nose wary,
it is a half-arm taller
than his Centurions.
He waits at the altar.
It is all legs and
beak,
draws blood from the priests
as they hold it down.
Nero approaches
with the drawn blade,
intones the prayer,
slashes the place
where gangly neck
and pink body converge.
draws blood from the priests
as they hold it down.
Nero approaches
with the drawn blade,
intones the prayer,
slashes the place
where gangly neck
and pink body converge.
The head comes
off.
The body leaps up
and out of the priest-hold,
spurts blood
all over Nero’s toga.
No one moves; no one utters
a syllable; all of Rome’s heart
The body leaps up
and out of the priest-hold,
spurts blood
all over Nero’s toga.
No one moves; no one utters
a syllable; all of Rome’s heart
skips a beat. Crowds
part
as the headless
horror,
runs out and down
the temple steps,
across the plaza, a blood Aetna
bespattering the paving stones.
Crowds part for its passing
until it reaches the Tiber
and plunges in.
across the plaza, a blood Aetna
bespattering the paving stones.
Crowds part for its passing
until it reaches the Tiber
and plunges in.
The Emperor
stands,
the knife in hand,
his toga bloodied, ruined.
The priests avert their eyes.
Centurions watch
as less-than-god hands
wipe blood on white linen;
they look at one another
and with a not-quite smile,
the same thought occurs
to each of them.
the knife in hand,
his toga bloodied, ruined.
The priests avert their eyes.
Centurions watch
as less-than-god hands
wipe blood on white linen;
they look at one another
and with a not-quite smile,
the same thought occurs
to each of them.
Tuesday, September 5, 2017
Variations on the Ibis
1
Artists are people
to whom coincidence
adheres, filings to their magnet consciousness.
My painter friend Riva points out
a small montage, a hulking splotch
with linked chains and a few squiggles.
“It won some prizes,” she tells me,
“But as for what it means —“ she shrugs.
My eyes reel into its story-window:
I see Prometheus chained, a Grand Inquisitor
in purple robes, and there, the white wings
of the gloating Zeus-eagle. “I can write this,”
I tell her. “Take it,” she said.
adheres, filings to their magnet consciousness.
My painter friend Riva points out
a small montage, a hulking splotch
with linked chains and a few squiggles.
“It won some prizes,” she tells me,
“But as for what it means —“ she shrugs.
My eyes reel into its story-window:
I see Prometheus chained, a Grand Inquisitor
in purple robes, and there, the white wings
of the gloating Zeus-eagle. “I can write this,”
I tell her. “Take it,” she said.
Another time she
shows me an etching,
a crinolin’d ghost shape a-dance
before a barren landscape. It sits
the bottom-most discard in a bottom drawer.
“That is the Empress Carlota!” I cry,
“And that is Queretaro where Maximilian died.”
So off I went and wrote a play.
a crinolin’d ghost shape a-dance
before a barren landscape. It sits
the bottom-most discard in a bottom drawer.
“That is the Empress Carlota!” I cry,
“And that is Queretaro where Maximilian died.”
So off I went and wrote a play.
On a graveyard walk
she stops, leans down
and picks up a squashed shard, some scrap
of one car’s fender run over by another.
“I’ll make something of this,” she told me.
I carry it home in my bag, then place
it absent-mindedly on dresser-top.
Months later, she visits and spies it,
atop a wood frame. I pick it up
to hand it back to her. Our eyes dance
upon the seeming-shapeless object,
and then to what’s inside my glass-framed box:
the Indonesian fruit-bat I nicknamed “Claudius.”
The shape of the found object precisely fills
the silhouette of the preserved fruit bat.
We smile. This is how the universe works us.
and picks up a squashed shard, some scrap
of one car’s fender run over by another.
“I’ll make something of this,” she told me.
I carry it home in my bag, then place
it absent-mindedly on dresser-top.
Months later, she visits and spies it,
atop a wood frame. I pick it up
to hand it back to her. Our eyes dance
upon the seeming-shapeless object,
and then to what’s inside my glass-framed box:
the Indonesian fruit-bat I nicknamed “Claudius.”
The shape of the found object precisely fills
the silhouette of the preserved fruit bat.
We smile. This is how the universe works us.
Small wonder, then,
that I am reading Egypt,
the lore of Thoth and Hermes, his totem
animals the Lower Kingdom’s lordly ibis,
the Upper Kingdom’s wise baboon,
when tea with Riva reveals a water color
mystery, a scimitar shape emerging
from a blue-gray mist, a river fog,
a scythe, perhaps, with a hand to weild it.
“No!” I said. “It is upside-down.”
And there, in lordly solitude,
stood the Egyptian ibis. I have it still.
Riva is gone, her mind first, and then her body,
the ka and the ba on out-of-kilter journey
across to the Land of Reeds in the West.
So now the ibis panting is in its place
at my compound shrine of Hermes-Thoth:
the ibis with kneeling scribe before it,
the ibis-headed god himself in sculpture;
the sacred baboon;
the head of Hermes; two small pyramids,
a hippo, and The Book of Coming Forth by Day.
the lore of Thoth and Hermes, his totem
animals the Lower Kingdom’s lordly ibis,
the Upper Kingdom’s wise baboon,
when tea with Riva reveals a water color
mystery, a scimitar shape emerging
from a blue-gray mist, a river fog,
a scythe, perhaps, with a hand to weild it.
“No!” I said. “It is upside-down.”
And there, in lordly solitude,
stood the Egyptian ibis. I have it still.
Riva is gone, her mind first, and then her body,
the ka and the ba on out-of-kilter journey
across to the Land of Reeds in the West.
So now the ibis panting is in its place
at my compound shrine of Hermes-Thoth:
the ibis with kneeling scribe before it,
the ibis-headed god himself in sculpture;
the sacred baboon;
the head of Hermes; two small pyramids,
a hippo, and The Book of Coming Forth by Day.
2
I asked a Greek
who’d been to Egypt,
an Alexandrian admittedly, about the ibis.
“Don’t mention ibises! Those filthy birds,
worse than the legendary Harpies, be sure.
Not just the stately water-strider
you see in those temple scrolls — no!
Packs of them in every garbage heap,
fish-trash and butcher dumping place.
They eat what jackals would scorn to swallow.
They eat anything! They gorge themselves
until their innards can take no more —
guts forty yards long, I can assure you —
until they’re fat as a pampered goose.
The ibis knows no repose from gluttony:
stuffed full, they go off to the water.
Then, cheeks and bill blown up,
they give themselves water enemas.
The stench amid the reeds
is not to be believed.
an Alexandrian admittedly, about the ibis.
“Don’t mention ibises! Those filthy birds,
worse than the legendary Harpies, be sure.
Not just the stately water-strider
you see in those temple scrolls — no!
Packs of them in every garbage heap,
fish-trash and butcher dumping place.
They eat what jackals would scorn to swallow.
They eat anything! They gorge themselves
until their innards can take no more —
guts forty yards long, I can assure you —
until they’re fat as a pampered goose.
The ibis knows no repose from gluttony:
stuffed full, they go off to the water.
Then, cheeks and bill blown up,
they give themselves water enemas.
The stench amid the reeds
is not to be believed.
No one will eat an
ibis, I tell you,
and fishermen at night have seen them
beak to belly in oral copulation
(You can look it up in Strabo, too!
I’m not making this up.)
and fishermen at night have seen them
beak to belly in oral copulation
(You can look it up in Strabo, too!
I’m not making this up.)
Now what this says
about the priests of Thoth,
those ibis-headed ministers
and their mystery rites
is best left to the imagination.
Would you eat at table with a man
who had such habits? One cup
his lips had touched could fell a village.
I’m not one to leap to conclusions
but I prefer my gods sunny, Greek, and clean.”
those ibis-headed ministers
and their mystery rites
is best left to the imagination.
Would you eat at table with a man
who had such habits? One cup
his lips had touched could fell a village.
I’m not one to leap to conclusions
but I prefer my gods sunny, Greek, and clean.”
Autumn of the Oligarchs
What if all the awful things that are happening are exactly what the one percents wants to happen, including near civil war and a nuclear "accident?" Here is my latest, and gloomiest poem in the series "Anniversarius: The Book of Autumn." It is satire, but in satire there is often a sad kernel of truth. Some people really wouldn't mind ending civilization, if "their kind" survived.
AUTUMN OF THE OLIGARCHS
AUTUMN OF THE OLIGARCHS
Come
September,
those dirty brown oak leaves
tumbling around like homeless persons
are not acceptable here.
Oak-leaf clusters, preserved and dried
in tones of cheerful red and orange
will make a suitable display
for our early-harvest luncheon.
The noise is worth it — those tawny Mexicans
leaf-blowing till every last derelict
of maple, birch, alder and sycamore
are hosed and bagged, and tucked away —
worth it to have a picture-perfect lawn
neat as a golf course.
those dirty brown oak leaves
tumbling around like homeless persons
are not acceptable here.
Oak-leaf clusters, preserved and dried
in tones of cheerful red and orange
will make a suitable display
for our early-harvest luncheon.
The noise is worth it — those tawny Mexicans
leaf-blowing till every last derelict
of maple, birch, alder and sycamore
are hosed and bagged, and tucked away —
worth it to have a picture-perfect lawn
neat as a golf course.
Come October,
and every last leaf will be gone.
The acorns shall have been harvested,
bird-nests removed.
and every last leaf will be gone.
The acorns shall have been harvested,
bird-nests removed.
Those pine cones
falling like hand-grenades:
one can scarcely keep up with them,
but go they must. The traps shall be set
for the aberrant beaver, the rabbit,
the ever-destructive mole.
As for the birds, the Ornithology Club
has come up with an “approved” list —
we’ll have drones with rifle-shots to cull the rest.
All of our poorer relatives patrol the woods
for deer and fox and all unwanted mammals.
The Approved Cat and her progeny, keep clear
the house and ground of rats, and mice, and voles.
As for the squirrels — anarchists all! — we make
their lives a misery with a pack of Approved Hounds
until we find a way to breed those rodents sterile
(a break-through that will come in handy
as we down-size — just think,
a whole continent all for the taking, all over again,
but I get ahead of myself —
one can scarcely keep up with them,
but go they must. The traps shall be set
for the aberrant beaver, the rabbit,
the ever-destructive mole.
As for the birds, the Ornithology Club
has come up with an “approved” list —
we’ll have drones with rifle-shots to cull the rest.
All of our poorer relatives patrol the woods
for deer and fox and all unwanted mammals.
The Approved Cat and her progeny, keep clear
the house and ground of rats, and mice, and voles.
As for the squirrels — anarchists all! — we make
their lives a misery with a pack of Approved Hounds
until we find a way to breed those rodents sterile
(a break-through that will come in handy
as we down-size — just think,
a whole continent all for the taking, all over again,
but I get ahead of myself —
Come November,
green turf, stripped-bare trees like telephone poles,
the grounds secure, the fences electrified,
we’ll settle in for the fall and winter.
There will be inconveniences, of course.
Next to the martini, an iodine tablet.
Old Master paintings all moved to a solid bunker
(Best of the Met slipped out by sleight-of-hand);
the dinosaurs and those quaint old dioramas
of Arctic and African species (fakes all in Manhattan
as long ago we stealthed away the originals).
Deep in a cave we have the best of the best
and we can visit any time, on trips to the vaults
where we’ve moved all our solid assets.
When things calm down, the missiles spent
and the Geiger-counter clicks are down to drip-drop;
when the cities are cleansed and the suburbs leveled —
just you wait for the turkey day to end all turkey days.
Done by Thanksgiving, the generals assured us,
just the one percent (us) and about five percent (them),
the ones we chose. By God, we’ll have stuffing,
cigars and brandy by the fireplace, a starry night.
green turf, stripped-bare trees like telephone poles,
the grounds secure, the fences electrified,
we’ll settle in for the fall and winter.
There will be inconveniences, of course.
Next to the martini, an iodine tablet.
Old Master paintings all moved to a solid bunker
(Best of the Met slipped out by sleight-of-hand);
the dinosaurs and those quaint old dioramas
of Arctic and African species (fakes all in Manhattan
as long ago we stealthed away the originals).
Deep in a cave we have the best of the best
and we can visit any time, on trips to the vaults
where we’ve moved all our solid assets.
When things calm down, the missiles spent
and the Geiger-counter clicks are down to drip-drop;
when the cities are cleansed and the suburbs leveled —
just you wait for the turkey day to end all turkey days.
Done by Thanksgiving, the generals assured us,
just the one percent (us) and about five percent (them),
the ones we chose. By God, we’ll have stuffing,
cigars and brandy by the fireplace, a starry night.
Come December,
sure as hell it’ll be a White Christmas.
sure as hell it’ll be a White Christmas.
Motherhood
I wish I had just dreamt this, but I saw it on YouTube. White supremacy, from Mom.
MOTHERHOOD
MOTHERHOOD
Trailer park
slattern, blonde,
holds close two flax-haired children.
“We need another genocide,”
she says to the camera,
more opioid mama than Viking
shield maiden.
holds close two flax-haired children.
“We need another genocide,”
she says to the camera,
more opioid mama than Viking
shield maiden.
“You know that
means killing?”
the reporter asks.
She nods. “I know. We need
to have another genocide.” —
“You know that means killing women,
and all their children with them?” —
Her eyes drop, then raise. “I know that.” —
“So why do we need another genocide?” —
“Them!” she shouts, pointing at progeny,
“So my children will have a chance.”
Husband, off camera: “That’s my woman.
Ain’t she something?”
the reporter asks.
She nods. “I know. We need
to have another genocide.” —
“You know that means killing women,
and all their children with them?” —
Her eyes drop, then raise. “I know that.” —
“So why do we need another genocide?” —
“Them!” she shouts, pointing at progeny,
“So my children will have a chance.”
Husband, off camera: “That’s my woman.
Ain’t she something?”
Dreamers
The hand extended to
an innocent child,
the hand snapped
back; the slap
back-handed, the
raised club,
the road-side stop,
the knock
three times at the
midnight door.
Dark-celled without a lawyer,
Dark-celled without a lawyer,
then bused to a
border, and over it.
One hand, with a
pen-stroke
(small fingers
tweeting), eight
hundred thousand
eye-blink exiles.
What list are you
on, reader,
and when does your
time come?
9/5/2017
Monday, August 28, 2017
Henry Hornbostel's Porter Hall/Baker Hall
A photo tour of Carnegie Mellon University's Porter Hall/Baker Hall, the work of architect Henry Hornbostel from 1905-1914. Architect Naomi Yoran, who designed the 2002 addition to the connected halls, gave me a guided tour and showed how the new addition was created to blend in with Hornbostel's original design. Connecting the two structures is a glass, modern "bridge," from which distinct details of Hornbostel's design can be viewed up close. Details include a spectacular, almost Art Nouveau Guastavino-tile covered curved staircase; and sconced lighting in wide corridors creating ceiling light patterns, steel-reinforced corners and doorways, with doors recessed. The new addition, unlike the original buildings, has a basement, where the Giant Eagle Auditorium was placed. Several pyramidal skylights admit light into the lobby of the basement area. At the top of the round stairway I found two antique proof presses, relics of the Carnegie Institute's printing school. It will take a long time to exhaust the fascinating geometries of this building, just one of Hornbostel's Pittsburgh treasures. Thanks to Naomi Yoran for the guided tour!
Thursday, August 17, 2017
An English Fantasia
Back when I owned a Neupert harpsichord in the 1980s, I did more improvising than playing, and I wrote down a theme and variations inspired by my various attempts to play music from The Fitzwilliam Virginal Book. This collection of Elizabethan keyboard pieces for virginal (a smallish harpsichord string sideways) or organ are the first real solo keyboard music in England.
Composers like Orlando Gibbons and John Bull and William Byrd graced its pages. Any number of the pieces seem to be based on lute music, and one frequently finds pieces all notated in C Major, but using the same accidentals to create various chords that might have been played on the lute (just my guess on why this is so).
A number of the pieces also have a lot of close-fingered melodies with imitation back and forth across a small span. So the theme I created has that same feel. It's not really a promising theme for variations but I had fun with it. A "skipping" variation uses dotted notes. A C-Minor variation was a devil to notate. Some bridge passages came from who-knows where. Then the theme is adapted into 5/4 time and the harpsichordist gets some trills and runs. The main theme returns at the end, played slowly, and ornamented with trills.
So here it is, for your enjoyment.
An English Fantasia on SoundCloud
Composers like Orlando Gibbons and John Bull and William Byrd graced its pages. Any number of the pieces seem to be based on lute music, and one frequently finds pieces all notated in C Major, but using the same accidentals to create various chords that might have been played on the lute (just my guess on why this is so).
A number of the pieces also have a lot of close-fingered melodies with imitation back and forth across a small span. So the theme I created has that same feel. It's not really a promising theme for variations but I had fun with it. A "skipping" variation uses dotted notes. A C-Minor variation was a devil to notate. Some bridge passages came from who-knows where. Then the theme is adapted into 5/4 time and the harpsichordist gets some trills and runs. The main theme returns at the end, played slowly, and ornamented with trills.
So here it is, for your enjoyment.
An English Fantasia on SoundCloud
Wednesday, August 2, 2017
"Death by X-Ray" - The Shostakovich Seventh Quartet
I wrote these program notes for a concert given in Providence in 2012 by the Jerusalem Quartet. This is an intense, short, and very weird string quartet, but worth the effort it takes to get to know it.
DMITRI SHOSTAKOVICH (1906-1975). String Quartet No. 7 in f#, Op 108 (March 1960)
-
Allegretto
-
Lento
-
Allegro
Written
in the same year that Shostakovich was forced to join the Communist
Party, this quartet is spared the tragic dimensions the composer put
into his Eighth Quartet, a virtual suicide note in music. Although it
cannot be separated from the times and circumstances in which it was
composed, this is an intensely personal work, an elegy for the
composer’s first wife Nina, who died in 1954.
The
work was premiered May 15, 1960 by the Beethoven Quartet in St.
Petersburg (then still Leningrad), and had its Moscow premiere at the
Moscow Conservatory on September 17 of the same year.
It
is the shortest of all of Shostakovich’s quartets, and there is the
risk of writing notes that take longer to read than the quartet takes
to listen to! But as is often the case with great music, composers
can compress much into a small interval of time.
The
composer had a life-plan for composing string quartets, intending to
compose one in each major and minor key, doing for the quartet
literature what Bach did for the keyboard in his Well-Tempered
Clavier. That said, the Seventh Quartet should have been in Eb
Major, following the scheme the composer was using. Instead, the
quartet is set in the moody and passionate key of F# Minor, which
puts it in company of Haydn’s “Farewell” symphony and Mahler’s
withering Tenth Symphony.
Shostakovich
often includes coded content in his work, and when you hear the first
theme in the opening Allegretto, a kind of sardonic, skipping melody,
you will immediately hear three repeated eighth notes, followed by a
rest, quite literally a “knock at the door.” In German folklore,
Death knocks three times at the door or window of a dying person, to
the horror of family members watching at the bedside. Considering how
many nights during the Stalin years, the composer expected a
different kind of “knock at the door” that would take him to the
Gulag, this gesture is richly suggestive. We are meant to recall
terrible times. (In the Tenth Symphony, Shostakovich alternated the
door-knock with the notes D-Eb-C-B, which are D-Es-C-H in German
notation for the composer’s initials, meaning, “Knock-knock-knock!
Shostakovich!”) So no matter how engaging the violin’s utterances
might be, the knock at the door is embedded in the theme.
There
is a break into hurried sixteenth notes, and a key change to Eb (the
“home” key Shostakovich planned to use originally!) with the
cello carrying the line, some very chromatic passages passing
it back to the violin, and then a bridge passage played in block
chords.
This
bridge brings us back to F# Minor, with the main theme played
pizzicato. This adds further to the grotesque atmosphere. It has the
air of a hushed conversation, and the pizzicato requires leaving out
the grace notes, so that the effect is a coded conversation, out of
earshot of Those Who Watch and Listen. The movement ends with
extensions of the “knock at the door” motif.
The
Lento is an eerie, almost minimalist movement, with no key
signature, played with the strings muted (con sordino). The
second violin plays an unsettling succession of arpeggios, which look
like a wave depicted on an oscilloscope. Viola and cello play
glissansdi at one point, adding to the weirdness of the
atmosphere. What is going on here? The clue, I think comes from the
biography of Nina Shostakovich. She was an experimental physicist who
spent months each year on Mt. Alagez in Armenia, engaged in cosmic
ray research. Like many Soviet researchers, she was exposed to
massive doses of radiation from radioactive materials, and from
poorly shielded X-ray equipment. She died from a radiation-induced
cancer. This music sounds to me almost like a science-fiction sound
track depicting radiation. I would venture to give this Lento
movement the nick-name “Death by X-Ray.”
The
final Allegro has, for most of its length, no key indication.
It is highly atonal, and since it is riddled with intermingled sharps
and flats, it must be a daunting task to play. Even though the
musical materials are spun out from motifs in the first movement, it
would seem to be a Dance of Death, with the skeletons from the X-Ray
now hammering away at a fiendish dance. The theme is passed among the
viola and the two violins as a canon, the strictest type of fugue
imitation (a melody played against itself, not against a second
theme). Even though what we hear would give Bach convulsions, it is a
Baroque concoction as conceived by a wrong-note revolutionary. This
is angry music depicting a universe that kills capriciously. Then,
abruptly, the “home key” of F# Minor asserts itself, with muted
strings. As the quartet slows down and softens to its conclusion,
there is no fist-shaking against Death (what is the use?), just a
quiet slipping away, life sitting at life’s deathbed, and a hint of
the ominous three-note “knock at the door.”
Shostakovich's String Quartet No 8
I wrote these notes in 2005 for a performance by the Chiarra Quartet in Providence, RI. At this time, there were still people claiming that Shostakovich was a "good Communist" and a loyal supporter of the Soviet Union. At the time I left Providence in 2015, I was still getting in arguments with musicians and academics about this. Hard to believe, but political fantasies die hard, and the facts be damned. Here are the notes, and I shall link to a YouTube video of the quartet as well.
Dmitri Shostakovich (1906-1975) String Quartet No. 8 in c minor, Op 110
Largo
Allegro molto
Allegretto
Largo
Largo
No work in the
string quartet literature is more intense or more emotionally
devastating than Shostakovich’s Eighth Quartet. It was long assumed
that this quartet was about
“The Victims of Fascism and War.” So says the epigraph in the
published score. So said all the program notes, and some of them
still say so. There is no denying the tragic sweep of this work that
seems to cry out like a dirge for millions of souls extinguished.
But since the
publication of Shostakovich’s memoir, Testimony,
in 1979, and more so the publication of the 1998 volume Shostakovich
Reconsidered, we now know that the Eighth
Quartet — however nobly it has served as a tombstone of the
Holocaust and World War II — was composed as a purely personal
self-epitaph, a suicide note in music.
The quartet’s obsessive use of
the four-note “DSCH” motto which spells out Shostakovich’s name
(Es is Eb and H is the note B in German notation); and its extensive
quiltwork of quotes from other Shostakovich music have always seemed
odd in a work that supposedly had a “public” purpose. At the very
least, the work has always been understood to contain “I suffered
too” as a sub-theme, including as it does quotes from works that
were banned for public performance through the Stalin years. What was
the Soviet Union’s “most loyal son” of composers doing and
saying?
It may come as a
surprise to many that Shostakovich did not become a member of the
Communist Party until 1960, his 54th
year. According to his wife Irina, he was finally blackmailed into
joining. In Testimony,
Shostakovich says, “When I wrote the Eighth Quartet, it was also
assigned to the department of ‘exposing fascism,’ You have to be
blind and deaf to do that, because everything in the quartet is as
clear as a primer. I quote Lady Macbeth,
the First and Fifth Symphonies. What does fascism have to do with
these? The Eighth is an autobiographical quartet; it quotes a song
known to all Russians: ‘Exhausted by the hardships of prison.’”
It was not until
1990 that Shostakovich’s colleague Lev Lebedinsky further confirmed
the Eighth Quartet’s link to this low point in the composer’s
life: “It was his farewell to life. He associated joining the Party
with a moral, as well as a physical death… [H]e had completed the
quartet and purchased a large number of sleeping pills, he played the
Quartet to me on the piano and told me with tears in his eyes that it
was his last work. He hinted at his intention to commit suicide.
Perhaps subconsciously he hoped that I would save him. I managed to
remove the pills from his jacket pocket and gave them to his son
Maxim, explaining to him the true meaning of the Quartet.”
The composer’s
son, Maxim, at a conference in 1992, added, “My father cried twice
in his life: when his mother died and when he came to say they’ve
made him join the Party. […T]his was sobbing, not just tears, but
sobbing.” Lebedinsky also reveals that “a much-trumpeted Party
plenum” was called to present Shostakovich for one and all to see
as a born-again Communist, and the event “deteriorated into a farce
due to … the unexpected absence of the composer!” Abject
apologies were made, and Shostakovich was dutifully enrolled as a
Party member, but clearly one to be watched.
In the limited
space we have to describe tonight’s work, it has seemed more
compelling to tell the truth
about this staggering composition than to engage in musical analysis.
Moreover, those who know Shostakovich’s music in depth are
“insiders” to this music, which resonates with themes from four
of his symphonies, several other chamber works, and the opera Stalin
hated, Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk
District. Better perhaps, to let the DSCH
motto take over and view the work as a phantasmagoria of musical
threads, woven with passion and musical genius. Since Shostakovich is
one of the truly great quartet composers, this work deserves to be
examined as pure music — but not now, and perhaps not for a long
time to come. Accept this quartet as a message in a bottle, a cry of
despair, a warning that collaboration with evil destroys the soul.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)